Inman (csinman) wrote,
Inman
csinman

And now for something completely sappy. Well, almost.

I just wrote the harshest review of someone else's story I think I've ever given, and while I'm terrified that I've discouraged the author, I'm very grateful that I understand what she did wrong, and not only that, but I have the skills to explain the errors and offer solutions. I have our awesome crit group to thank.

Recently someone posted on my f-list (I can't find it now, so maybe it wasn't so recent) about how much they love their critique partners. I figured I'd tell you why mine are so valuable to me:

criada has a mind that can create and track an entire planet. Plenty of fantasy authors think they can do that, but few really can. If I ever need help with political intrigue, world economics, religion, or other incredibly complex elements, she has much to offer.

kehrli is like a special robot built to absorb inconsistencies and spit out solutions. What else would you expect from a disciple of science but a keen sense of logic and a highly tuned suspension-of-disbeliefometer?

kaerfel understands the structure of an effective story better than anyone else who has dissected my work. I've learned alot about manipulating a reader's mind from her, despite the fact that she might be one of the most guileless people I know.

tlcadence has gifts for visceral description and instant characterization, two talents I lust after. She's the member of our group who writes the least SF, and her unique perspective is invaluable in separating universally appealing themes from genre specific ones.

When rith26's fat ass shows up, he's pretty funny. I don't know if he gives good critique, SINCE HIS FAT ASS NEVER SHOWS UP. :)
Tags: crit: i love you guys
Subscribe

  • Rainforest Writers Village Recap

    There are lots of rumors about what actually happens at Rainforest, so I thought I'd give you a photographic account of what it's really like at this…

  • If the police call...

    ...and ask who was responsible for teaching me that terrorism is a sound business model, point them toward tbclone47. To prove I'm not…

  • Workshop & Weakly Story Club 2009.003

    Eileen Gunn presented "Wit and Tragedy: Writing the Savagely Funny Story" today to fifteen eager participants, one of whom was me! It was fantastic.…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 8 comments